Listomania #5 — My Favorite Fundy Traditions
It’s been a couple of weeks without a “Listomania”, so I thought I’d lighten the mood with a fresh one. One of my favorite blogs in the whole blogosphere is “Stuff Christians Like” by Prodigal Jon. Maybe it’s just his way of writing or the fact that those of us who grew up evangelical/fundamentalist can relate to the things in which he finds humor, but the guy just cracks me up every time I read him. We pompous religious types sometimes take ourselves WAY too seriously and sometimes it would do us good to look at the caricatures we tend to become.
So, this edition of “Listomania” is “Fundy Traditions that Made Me What I Am Today”. With tongue firmly in cheek, I begin.
- The New Year’s Eve “Watchnight Service”
The annual New Year’s Eve Watchnight Service was a fixture in most evangelical churches of my youth. It constituted of a service that started around 7:00 with lots of singing (see item #6), the “main” sermon by the pastor, if there was an associate he was able to speak too and then all the “preacher boys” were allowed to get up and rant and rave for about 15 minutes each. Then there would be refreshments in the basement consisting of vegetable trays and pimento cheese sandwiches washed down with instant tea. After that intermission, it was back to the auditorium for the “movie” (a rare treat because many of us were not allowed to attend the Cinema House). These movies were from one of three categories — Billy Graham, Bob Jones University Unusual Films (Sheffey, Flame in the Wind) or Independent (I could write a whole blog on Estes Pirkle’s – no I did NOT make up that name – “The Burning Hell” or that cult-classic “If Footmen Tire You What Will Horses Do?” which you have to youtube to believe.) Finally, at about 11:55, everyone would gather up front of the church and “Pray out the old year and pray in the new year”. There was always a sneaking suspicion that the rapture just might occur at the stroke of midnight – or at least it seemed that way to me.
- The 8-Day Revival
Now this was a great tradition. Starting on one Sunday, the 8-Day Revival ran until the following Sunday night. It always involved a guest speaker – and if you were lucky – guest music as well. The evangelist was usually a firebrand from somewhere “down South”. Often they were of the “wind-sucker” variety which means, if you really got them wound up, they would suck the price tag off Minnie Pearl’s hat if she was sitting 12 pews back. Each night was a different theme to encourage you to bring guests. There was “pack-a-pew” night, family night, neighbor night, co-worker night, etc… If you brought the most guests all week, you might win the giant Family Bible. Sometimes the invitations for the 8-Day Revival would last longer than the sermons and to this day I know all the verses to “Just As I Am”, “Almost Persuaded” and “Softly and Tenderly.” At the end of the 8-Day Revival, we needed a family seminar because everyone was so grouchy from sleep deprivation that we were at each other’s throats. Traditionally, there was a spring and a fall revival.
- Vacation Bible School
Vacation Bible School – also known as VBS – usually happened during the hottest week of the summer. It involved flannel graph – that unique precursor to Veggie Tales – wherein Bible lessons were taught using cut-out figures with flocking on the back of them that let them stick to backgrounds of flannel. Super Kewl. There was also arts and crafts time that used up a year’s supply of bleach bottles, pipe cleaners, cotton balls and if you were blessed – plaster-of-paris plaques! Finally, there was cookie break supplied by the kind ladies of the church who brought cookies the two Sunday’s before VBS. To wash down the cookies there was also “Bug Juice” aka Kool-Aid which only came in three flavors in those days – Red, Purple and Orange. Sometimes it was even cold. And yes, there was usually at least one gnat floating in the big giant bucket. Bug Juice lost a lot of its appeal to me when I accidentally burst into the kitchen one morning to find Sister Lucille (a rather large lady with an odd shaped mole on her forearm) leaned over the giant plastic vat with her sleeve rolled up (on the moley arm) mixing it with her bare hand. But her skin did have a nice smurfy look for the rest of the day.
- Summer Youth Camp
Summer youth camp was the highlight of the summer after you outgrew VBS. It involved loading up a huge suitcase and all your friends onto a school bus that migrant workers would have refused to ride. You always added a few extra hours into the travel schedule for the inevitable breakdown or three. We’d pack our lunches to save time and we’d lustily sing 99-Bottles-of-Coke-on-the-Wall (cuz’ good Baptist kids didn’t sing “Beer” on the wall – except for a few really rebellious guys, but we didn’t do it real loud because many of the spiritual girls were pretty and they kind of frowned on us even joking about beer.) Our camp of choice was the Bill Rice Ranch in Murfreesboro, TN and it was the best camp ever. Urine-stained mattresses, cold showers, red Tennessee mud everywhere and mosquitoes the size of pterodactyls did not diminish the thrills of melon marches, frog races, swimming in a REAL swimming pool, camp skits and the Friday Night “Banquet” where we all picked a pretty girl to sit by. We all made “decisions” to be better teens on the last night and promised to cut our hair short, throw away our Carpenter’s albums and quit holding hands with our girlfriends in the back of the bus. (That last commitment didn’t last real long if we left for the drive home immediately after the service.) Then we’d trade addresses with our new best friends whom we never wrote to or saw ever again and sang camp songs all the way home.
- Testimony Service
Testimony service at an evangelical church can have all the drama and humor of open mic night at the local karaoke bar. You just never know what is going to pop out of someone’s mouth. Old-school testimony givers always start off thanking God for their salvation and sometimes give you the details. If you pay attention, you’ll eventually get to where you can give it as well as they do. Then there’s the awkward silence times when no one gets up forever and the preacher then says “If someone doesn’t get up soon I’m going to sing” followed by nervous giggling and then three people stand up all at once and it just gets even more awkward. Speaking of awkward, there’s always the chance that some maroon is going to stand up and give some sort of gut-wrenching confession that makes someone else in his family look bad as in “I just want to praise the Lord for His grace in my marriage and the fact that my wife has finally repented of her stubbornness and allowed me to move off the couch and back into our matrimonial bed.” My personal favorite is the testimony service right before Thanksgiving or around some other holiday when some total stranger who has never been in the church before and, if the truth be known is about three sheets in the wind (if you know what I mean) and just feels like he MUST stand and give some testimony that is incoherent or borderline heretical. Good times.
- Sing-Your-Favorite-Hymn Service
This is almost always reserved for an evening service and consisted of having the song leader urge the congregation to shout out their favorite hymn number or title and then we got to see if the piano player could play by note or by ear. These usually went quite well at first with three or four old favorites shouted out and then someone would get cocky and shout out some old English Anglican Hymn that was previously only sung in a cathedral on the Ides of March accapella by Gregorian monks. The song leader bravely would tackle it with tepid effort as the pianist leaned close to the page and hit chords on the old upright that sounds like a like she was playing with her toes. Oddly, the person who called it would be singing like they had the solo part for “Memories” at the Broadway Musical “Cats” obliviously to the caterwauling that was going on around them. After one verse, everyone giggled nervously and someone would shout out a super familiar song and the tension would be broken. The congregation sang with gusto and the relieved song leader would wave his arms like he was swatting flies and all was well again in the sing-your-favorite-hymn service.
- Potluck Dinners
I personally believe that there’s a high probability that the Marriage Supper of the Lamb might be potluck. If so, you can count on the fact that there will be sections for the various goodies. First will be the salads. I think this is the fake-out section. They try to get you to load your flimsy paperplate with salads so that you won’t take too much fried chicken later and the people at the end of the line won’t have to get surly. Following the salads, you will find pickles and raw veggie platters. Then there’s Casserole Row. There’s more ground up breadcrumbs and cornflakes hiding the-Lord-only-knows-what than you can shake a stick at. What isn’t covered with crumbs and flakes is smothered in some type of Campbell’s soup. Don’t ask; don’t tell. Then there’s the meat section. The hog farmers bring a ham – count on it. If you are in the Carolinas – there will be pulled pork BBQ – Eastern (vinegary) and Western (tomato based) – but all quite tasty. (You just can’t ruin BBQ.) Then it’s the staple of the Potluck — Fried Chicken. There are three types of fried chicken. There’s the store-bought chicken (for shame, for shame – except when it’s from the Colonel and I’ll take extra-crispy, please). That’s followed by the homemade done-from scratch chicken. (If you’re in the country and you look carefully, sometimes you can actually find pinfeathers on your piece. If you don’t know what pinfeathers are, again, I suggest – don’t ask; don’t tell.) Finally, there’s the people who got store-bought chicken and then put it in their own container to make people think that they actually made it themselves. Others will do the same trick with potato salad and slaw – like we can’t identify the KFC signature sides. Depending on the time of the year, you’ll also get preserves, deviled eggs, fresh tomatoes and TONS of zucchini bread. Of course, there’s a whole separate dessert section, but again – that’s for another blog article.
- Missionary Speakers
Ah yes, the missionary speaker. As a boy, we’d take bets on how long it would be before one of the following happened – a) the slide screen would collapse with a zip and a thud (it was always fun to watch the old lady with the hair net jump when that happened); b) a slide would jam or c) a slide would be upside down. Of course, occasionally you’d hit a trifecta and all three would happen. The narration always included a picture of some poor third-world family and the missionary would say, “This is the family of Pedro Gonzalez. Pray for Pedro’s mother. She’s Catholic. She’s almost ready to convert, but the priest is intimidating her.” Every single time. Then there would be Q and A time when people would ask travelogue-type questions. Then we’d hold our breath – hoping against hope that we’d be able to take an offering and go home. But did that ever happen? NOoooooo. THEN there was the missionary sermon when the poor missionary would do his best to have one of us surrender to go to the mission field. The invitation would continue until someone gave in and went forward to “pray about it” or express their willingness to go (which is short of actually saying I’m definitely going) and then we’d go home.
- Wednesday Night Prayer Meetings
Prayer meetings were held after a Bible study. That’s why they often called them “Wednesday Night Prayer and Bible Study Meetings”. Eventually, people decided to shorten them and most churches now just have a Bible study and hand out a prayer sheet which people leave in the car the rest of the week. The Bible study was usually a study of a book of the Bible. Then came the Prayer Time. This began with prayer requests – the general requests (prayer for our leaders, our church, etc…), the sick (Aunt Bertha’s second cousin’s neighbor who has a leaky gall bladder and so on) and the unsaved (the regulars followed by a few new ones) and then the Pastor would ask “How many of you have an unspoken prayer request?” This was for those who had something going on they didn’t want to blurt out in front of everyone, so instead, one just furtively raises their hand and let’s people speculate about what it is. Then the pastor would generally call on 2-4 people to pray and he’d close. This was a time of high anxiety as a good pick meant that prayer time wouldn’t be long, but the wrong pick – well, I hope you packed a snack. There were different types of “pray-ers”. There was the “Voice of God” pray-er who had a booming voice and prayed to the God of Jereboam, Rehaboam and all the Boam Boys – Johasaphat and all the Phat Phellows, and so on. There was also the “Lordiac” pray-er. This was someone who couldn’t utter more than three consecutive words in their prayers without injecting the word “Lord” as in “Lord, we thank you, Lord, for the beautiful, Lord, day, Lord, that we enjoyed, Lord.” The record number of “Lords” in a Lordiac prayer that I can recall was 121. When I announced that I had counted the number of “Lords” in Bro. Kent’s prayer that night my dad was ready to rail on me for my impiety except my mom piped up and announced that she had counted 122 “Lords”. The rest of the ride home was rather quiet that night.
- The “Right-Hand of Fellowship”
The “Right-Hand-of-Fellowship” ritual is a time when everyone shakes hands with their neighbors. Because good Baptists sit in the same exact spot like they built the pew themselves, that meant that you generally shook hands with the same six people every service. Except for us teen-age guys, who used the opportunity to find the cute girls and shake their hands long and slow. Also, if you were a visitor, you got your arm halfway shaken off. The other time you extended the RHF was at the end of the service when someone came forward at the end of the service for a “big” decision like joining the church, surrendering to the ministry, quitting smoking or something like that. Oddly, everyone in the church seemed to come down with colds at the exact same time every year.
- The Church Business Meeting
Church business meetings were generally once a month and were rather perfunctory. They consisted of the reading of the minutes, someone reading the check register for the month and voting the new members in. Occasionally however, there would be an exciting meeting that I swear must have been held during the full moon. This was when normally placid, sweet-natured people who smelled of Old Spice and Este Lauder turned into snarling, snapping beasts that would sometimes threaten to “take it out to the parking lot”. You usually knew when a bad business meeting was a brewing because someone would ask, “When’s the next business meeting?” No one cared if there was a business meeting except when there was going to be a rumble. Sometimes there was an organized effort. You could tell when that was going to occur because attendance at Wednesday Night Prayer and Bible Study would suddenly spike with dozens of people that hadn’t been seen in church for months. Often the pastor would deliver his Bible study that night in a trembly voice and would constantly wipe his brow with a handkerchief. On those nights, he always called on the “Voice of God” pray-ers.
- Sword Drills
I heart sword drills. These were exercises when the game was to be the first person to find a verse of Scripture called out. The leader would say, “Draw Swords!” (That’s Christian code for raise your Bible – the swift, powerful and two-edged version – above your head) He’d then call out a Scripture reference – Psalm 1:9 (Sometimes they’d try to fool us by saying Hezekiah 3:16 and then all the newbies would search frantically while the rest of us “old evangelical kid pros would snicker piously). Then they’d say “Go!”. The first person to find the verse would stand and read the first few words and if it was correct, they’d get a point. The sign of a real Sword Drill champ was to have enough verses memorized that you could fake having found the verse and pretend to read it when you were actually just quoting it.
So that’s my list. It’s a long one, but once I got started, I couldn’t stop. Now for my sensitive brethren and sisterns that think I’m crossing some sort of sanctified line with my reminiscing, let me say without hesitation that I LOVED growing up an evangelical fundy kid. It was a GREAT way to grow up and I wouldn’t trade it for anything. My memories of those days in a little country church make for great family stories and they are reminders of the depth of my personal commitment to Christ and His Word today.
But, I’m guessing that some of you have your own “favorite” fundy traditions. So, share them here and let’s all laugh together!
VickiS. said,
September 9, 2008 @ 9:33 pm
I’ve experienced all 12 phenomena. Actually, I think this exact list of activities were included somewhere in our church by-laws…I would just add the Easter sunrise service that everyone dreaded pulling themselves out of bed for at dark-thirty every Easter yet you always “felt the Spirit” when that sun peaked over the horizon.
Jonathan Charles said,
September 10, 2008 @ 8:44 am
Good list. Most of these things are still worth doing. The two I’d strike are the week-long revival and any kind of service that involves staying up late or getting up early. Most pastors I know of who still have revival meetings admit that after the little spark it gives a church immediately following the revival, that there are few if any lasting results. And, anyway, to what end is a pastor preaching the other 51 weeks out of the year if it isn’t to see people being renewed in their walk with Christ?
Jungle Mom said,
September 10, 2008 @ 8:52 am
Getting your tongue stuck in those little communion cups!!!
And did you ever sing, “Well, the showers at the Bill Rice Ranch are cold,
Amen ,brother, amen”?
Pam said,
September 10, 2008 @ 9:27 am
Thanks for a great start to my morning! Made me homesick for the little country church from MY youth…sometimes I have regretted that my sons didn’t experience some of this.
How about families taking monthly turns cleaning the building/mowing the grass?
(btw, we’re praying for the people in Cuba)
Erin Stalnaker said,
September 10, 2008 @ 9:43 am
Growing up in an Independent Fundamental Baptist Church, Bethlehem Baptist in northern Virginia (that made NBC look *very* liberal, I might add), gave me every single one of these memories!
You forgot to add that the “Sing Your Favorite Hymn” service also meant that the congregation would sing all 4 verses of the hymn instead of skipping verse 3!
J. Brian McKillop said,
September 10, 2008 @ 9:49 am
That was great, and brought back many good memories. I remember Ken Anderson Films from Watchnight Service and Camp.
Josh Benfield said,
September 10, 2008 @ 10:21 am
I completely identify with the sword drills. I was the sword drill champ most of the time and I remember quoting some verses from memory when I knew them. I still have my “sword drill Bible”. It’s pages didn’t stick and it was small enough that my hands as a child could maneuver through the pages easily.
I wanted to tack onto the revival one, too. Growing up at Northside, we not only had revivals, we had tent revivals. We’d put up a tent in the ballfield, assuming that would be more attractive to guests, maybe? And, then, we’d get the windsucker that you spoke of and the long invitation guy. Good times.
I also remember the pressure I felt to raise my hand for an unspoken, because if I didn’t, it meant somehow that I was less spiritual than the rest.
I feel like there are a million stories to tell of growing up in church, especially in indy, fundy church life.
But, like you said, I wouldn’t trade it for the world. I don’t want to go back, but I have great memories!!
Oh, one more. The Trail of Tribulation at Halloween time. We would carve a trail through the woods on the church property and act out some of the random parts of the book of Revelation. One of the stops that I worked in, we actually drug a “planted” person in the group into “hell”. And, there was always an invitation at the end. Ummm, I might feel guilty for ever having done that.
Awesome listomania!
Justin said,
September 10, 2008 @ 3:18 pm
Good list Dan. I remember all these growing up. I definitely think the October 31st “Harvest Party” should be added to the list. Since good Christians didn’t celebrate “Satan’s holiday,” my fundy church would have an alternative called a Harvest party. All the kids would dress up like their favorite Bible Character and they would go around the church with bags and get lots of candy. Of course, most of the kids knew that they were just celebrating Haloween but at least a few of the parents thought that maybe God wouldn’t know the difference.
Jonathan Charles said,
September 11, 2008 @ 8:58 pm
This isn’t funny, but one fundy tradition I’m glad I’ve put away is the bringing of couples who’ve had premarital sex before the church to ask the church’s forgiveness. I saw this practiced over and over and yet there isn’t a biblical basis for it. What there is a biblical basis for is the public rebuke of an elder and informing the congregation of an unrepentant member after the first 2 steps of church discipline have been attempted (Mt. 18). Who started this practice? And why was it only applied to young people who got pregnant out of wedlock? If the couple is sorry, why did anything more need to be said?
Gordon Cloud said,
September 12, 2008 @ 2:58 am
Don’t forget the bus ministry and children’s church.
bryan baskin said,
September 12, 2008 @ 12:00 pm
One amendment to the fried chicken rule: if KFC is brought, the chances are rare that you will get any because it is always the first to go. In 13 years at my home church, I think I got KFC 3 times. Incidentally, original is the best. You could say original is “fundamental” whereas extra crispy is neo-orthodox. That puts me in mind of another addition to your list: you cannot be a true indy fundy if you have never sat through sermons on the evils of isms and people that 9 out of 10 people in the pews have never heard of (Eg: neo-orthodoxy; Karl Barth; etc.). Cordially, Bryan
Ben R. said,
September 12, 2008 @ 1:23 pm
I think the one fundy tradition that I loved is the special Wednesday night or Sunday night service where a guest speaker would share his testimony about being saved from the evils of rock music. I remember hearing how the current rock music was a carry-over from the music of the pagan, tribal savages in Africa. Then the usually stories of demon-possession or cardiac arrest that would ensue on unsuspecting teenagers that always listend to rock music. Usually this was followed by a record, 8 track, or tape throw away/buring.
Boy, those were the good ‘ole days!
john brown said,
September 14, 2008 @ 9:55 pm
Special song request. LOL. My dad was leading the singing in a small church I didn’t like because I was in 8th grade and it was tiny and I had always been to very large churches so I was not real thrilled to be there to start with. Anyway, I held up my hand and requested the National Anthem. Needless to say it was NOT appreciated.
Marc Rhodes said,
September 15, 2008 @ 9:48 am
This post was hilarious. Seriously, I laughed out loud reading this. My favorite one was the Wednesday Night Prayer and Bible study. We recently did a small groups study on prayer and we covered those type of “pray-ers”. Great satire - I love it.
Jonathan said,
September 15, 2008 @ 1:35 pm
Brilliant! I would note a couple things:
1. McDonald’s Orange Drink at VBS - it might have been just my generation…
2. The Sword Drill anathema - when you find out the kid that just beat you and got the mini candy bar had a *gasp* Bible with thumb tabs!!!! NOOOOOO!!!!!
Fundamentalist Traditions at DowBlog said,
September 15, 2008 @ 3:23 pm
[…] Drop what you’re doing and go read Dan Burrell’s article on his Favorite Fundy Traditions. […]
Mike McKay said,
September 15, 2008 @ 3:29 pm
Here’s one for you: the 5th Sunday of the month (of which there are 2 during most years, I think) was Youth Night during the Sunday evening service. Teens picked the songs (all the ones the gray-heads disliked), gave the announcements (word for word from the bulletin), read the Scripture passage (anything except Song of Solomon, please), and–if there was a senior boy who had been called by God, or who simply could be compelled–sometimes even gave the message. I preached that message a time or two, and I always figured people would want to fire the pastor and hire me at the next business meeting because I was just so doggone pious.
Leonard Waterman said,
September 15, 2008 @ 11:57 pm
Though these were not a weekly, monthly or yearly traditions like most the predominant items on the previous list, something should be said about the major church dramas of:
1.) going through the process of a pastoral search where most of the teens were only interested in how many kids the family had, how close in age they were to you and whether they were of the same or opposite sex (younger teens wanting same sex children to play with - older teens wanting the opposite to breath some new life into the dating pool.
2.) the building program complete with the series of messages through Nehemiah on building the walls around Jerusalem IN 52 DAYS!!!! and the gigantic white wooden thermometer in the lobby displaying “OUR GIVING GOAL” and “HOW MUCH WE’VE GIVEN SO FAR” blazed in red.
3.)the church split that soon followed one or both of the previous events that left one group with a new but now mostly empty building that they couldn’t afford, and another group looking for a pastor and a building so they could start this cycle all over again.
you’re weird « wegotITgood said,
September 16, 2008 @ 4:32 pm
[…] that express some of the stange practices of the Christian community (Stuff Christians Like & Whirled Views). I can relate to a lot of these. Enjoy some laughs on me. I hope I am not that […]
patrick said,
September 17, 2008 @ 10:42 am
oh wow… how did this happen… how in the world did peeps ever get there?
lucretia said,
September 17, 2008 @ 1:38 pm
What about “foot washing” nuff said…
ben schettler said,
October 2, 2008 @ 2:58 am
That is the absolute funniest things on fundyism I have ever read in my life. You are half man half genius deity of satire.
You did forget to add Old fashion Sunday, the organ and the split service. (The awkward once-a-year teen night where the guys and the girls had the christian purity talk in different places.)